---
slug: paper-vogel-j-h-1991-uninvited-guests-a-thermodynamic-approach-to-resource-allocation
title: Vogel (1991): Uninvited Guests – A Thermodynamic Approach to Resource Allocation
canonical: https://miscsubjects.com/a/paper-vogel-j-h-1991-uninvited-guests-a-thermodynamic-approach-to-resource-allocation
---

## The Work and Its Author

Joseph H. Vogel published "Uninvited Guests: A Thermodynamic Approach to Resource Allocation" in Prometheus, volume 9, issue 2, pages 332-345, in 1991. The article applies nonequilibrium thermodynamics to economic resource allocation. Vogel contrasts neoclassical economics with a deterministic and reductionist version of nonequilibrium thermodynamics called DARNET.

Vogel holds that the second law of thermodynamics supplies a unified basis for phenomena that economics currently treats as separate add-ons.

## Core Results

The article establishes that order in physical, biological, and social systems arises through the dissipation of energy gradients. Maximum entropy production in open systems serves as the mechanism that generates structural complexity. DARNET deduces environmental degradation, nonrational behavior, and ethical constraints directly from thermodynamic propositions rather than grafting them onto a reversible model.

Vogel presents DARNET as a candidate paradigm that replaces the assumption of reversibility with the entropy law. The result is a simpler functional core that nevertheless accounts for observed complexities in allocation.

## Exact Primary Passages

Abstract: "A theory of resource allocation is emerging from the science of nonequilibrium thermodynamics (NET). The deterministic and reductionist version of NET (DARNET), like neoclassical economics, is functionally simple; however, unlike neoclassical economics, it invites structural complexities. Some of these complexities are behavioural (e.g., nonrational behaviour and ethics) and are implied by the human evolutionary paradigm subsumed within DARNET; other complexities are physical (e.g., environmental degradation) and are implied directly from core propositions of DARNET. The case for a paradigm shift to DARNET is presented."

Introduction: "The law that entropy always increases – the second law of thermodynamics – holds, I think, the supreme position among the laws of Nature. ... This passage from Eddington can only be ignored by mainstream economists. As a theory of resource allocation, economics has evolved by analogising Newtonian mechanics to social phenomena; in its neoclassical form, economics rests on the assumption of reversibility which is clearly 'against the second law'."

On order from dissipation: "The ineluctable truth that order is out of order is the phenomenological starting point of the DARNET program. DARNET advocates argue that the reason for complexity in chemical, living, and social structures is entropy production; the method to describe the emergence of such structures is maximisation."

On the postulate: "The extension of maximum entropy production in isolated systems to maximum entropy production in open systems is controversial even among NET advocates. Maximum entropy production in open systems, i.e., systems that can exchange energy or matter with their environments, is not a fact. It is a postulate. However, the postulate is a powerful one in generating testable hypotheses."

## Convergence Patterns Evidenced

The work touches energy flow to structure. Energy gradients degrade and produce ordered configurations in open systems. It addresses flow networks through resource circulation and environmental sinks. Bounded chaos appears in the tension between maximum entropy production and observed stable allocations. Memory enters via evolutionary paradigms that carry forward constraints on behavior. Scale invariance is implicit in the reduction from isolated thermodynamic systems to social aggregates.

These patterns align with the grain of reliable structural outcomes from energy flows across scales.

## Relation to the OIP/GRAIN Synthesis

Vogel supplies a thermodynamic foundation for the lower rungs of the Ladder: difference (energy gradients) produces flow that yields structure (allocations and organizations). The reader-economist sits inside the dissipative system and must account for that embedding when modeling allocation. DARNET therefore supports the Mirror Layer requirement that models remain consistent with the observer's position within the energy-dissipating whole.

The distance to the full synthesis remains large. Vogel stops at resource allocation and ethics; he does not extend the argument to life, mind, or protocol-level invocation and receipt mechanisms. The synthesis treats his work as one concrete bridge from thermodynamics to social description rather than a completed map.

## Honest Limits and Disconfirming Edges

The maximum entropy production postulate for open systems is explicitly labeled a postulate, not an established law. Reduction to thermodynamic description leaves open questions about the status of choice and free will. Vogel notes the language of economics becomes an issue under DARNET.

A reductionist objection in the style of Weinberg holds that thermodynamic constraints supply necessary but not sufficient conditions for social outcomes. Empirical testing of DARNET hypotheses in real allocation systems remains limited. The article itself presents the case for paradigm shift rather than completed empirical validation.

Vogel references earlier thermodynamic economists (Daly, Georgescu-Roegen) but positions DARNET as a more reductionist alternative that competes for paradigm status rather than merely complementing existing fields.

## Claims

The article contains no human-subject data. All material assertions receive the following atomic treatment in the claims array.

## Sources

Primary source is the 1991 Prometheus article. Secondary context appears in related thermodynamic-economics literature by Georgescu-Roegen and others cited within the text.
