# How an AI evidence record preserves why two peer-review committees disagreed

Revision history of https://miscsubjects.com/a/peer-review-derivation-record

revisions held: 8 · showing all

## Revision 7 — 2026-08-02T02:57:20.324Z

- title: How an AI evidence record preserves why two peer-review committees disagreed
- status: published
- bytes: 14636
- hash: e999b644dfeeeeaead282c91ee34b4b14fa434d80cc1f57a5d6afe12316a3492

## Revision 6 — 2026-08-02T02:15:31.133Z

- title: How an AI evidence record preserves why two peer-review committees disagreed
- status: published
- bytes: 14636
- hash: 71dcbdee0e37b4336e22bd9a089e7ee7308f1982542865b7f91abbeb701162f8

## Revision 5 — 2026-08-02T02:00:47.016Z

- title: How an AI evidence record preserves why two peer-review committees disagreed
- status: published
- bytes: 14636
- hash: ab29ccc0476d7aae32c30942f8d411d62edebc52dc4e1f8457c48886375bc3e7

## Revision 4 — 2026-08-01T23:55:44.537Z

- title: Two committees reviewed the same papers and disagreed a quarter of the time — twice. Nothing recorded why, until now
- status: published
- bytes: 14636
- hash: 01dff129fbb0bd30867c824fd3cfba066eb4753419b4d9f182da8c777012aa24

## Revision 3 — 2026-08-01T22:45:43.873Z

- title: Two committees reviewed the same papers and disagreed a quarter of the time — twice. Nothing recorded why, until now
- status: published
- bytes: 14636
- hash: 93de683fadd849377281606d8879fd7de488916a4d652b5e92cb2e9af8a5382c

## Revision 2 — 2026-08-01T22:44:03.374Z

- title: Two committees reviewed the same papers and disagreed a quarter of the time — twice. Nothing recorded why, until now
- status: published
- bytes: 14636
- hash: 8ebc66def75c182955b92cbb504a48bc0345b07fd3242bbe93ba812044cc3dc2

## Revision 1 — 2026-08-01T22:18:36.373Z

- title: Two NeurIPS committees disagreed on a quarter of the same papers, twice. Nothing records why. Here is a review format in which disagreement is a comparable record.
- status: published
- bytes: 14636
- hash: 486d6829a889fed84e99f863c25039b51e7065b4d0cd15ac98bddcfb261b8e22

## Revision 0 — 2026-07-30T15:02:11.919Z

- title: Two NeurIPS committees disagreed on a quarter of the same papers, twice. Nothing records why. Here is a review format in which disagreement is a comparable record.
- status: published
- bytes: 14613
- hash: ffdf4020279264b593dbb51a6d74e7aa60d89d5c54d4d86d852bd79355a599d5