Murray’s name appears on the endorsement of a Napa airport bidder
A Chamber endorsement and a vendor named in the same proposal connect Pedroza’s campaign treasurer to the failed competition. Napa awarded two 30-year leases after direct negotiations.
On 6 July 2020, Napa Chamber of Commerce President Travis Stanley endorsed Superior Aviation’s bid to operate at Napa County Airport. The proposal was submitted under the Napa Valley AVAtion name and identified the Superior Aviation operation and Scott L. Powell. On the endorsement’s letterhead was Chamber board chair Michael Alan Murray, who also served as Alfredo Pedroza’s campaign treasurer and Napa Recycling & Waste Services’ chief financial officer. The same proposal named Napa Recycling as its intended waste and recycling provider.
Open the three original source pages as a PDF
The endorsement places the Chamber’s support inside a specific airport bid, alongside a proposed vendor relationship involving its chair’s employer. Stanley signed the letter. Murray’s appearance on the letterhead establishes his listed office; the letter does not record who authorized the endorsement or whether he participated in that decision. The Chamber’s applicable endorsement policy, board minutes and any delegated authority would establish how such support was approved.
Murray’s roles in the bid and the waste franchise
Stanley addressed the letter to Leigh Sharp, a county Public Works deputy director who helped screen the bids. He wrote that Superior had been a President’s Circle member for more than two years and that he regularly saw aviation executive Joe Hansen at community events. Stanley signed the endorsement. The letter identifies Murray through his Chamber role and the bid names his employer as a prospective vendor. AVAtion withdrew before it secured a lease.
Section 7.7.3 names Napa Recycling & Waste Services among the local providers the bidder proposed to use. That is PDF page 37, numbered 26 in the proposal. Attachment 6, PDF page 76, separately says the proposed Hangar29 restaurant would send organic waste to the company’s commercial food-compost program.
Murray’s role in a separate county decision is recorded directly. On 24 September 2019 he presented a proposed increase of about 24% in garbage and recycling rates for unincorporated Zone One. Pedroza moved to adopt it and all five supervisors voted yes. Murray served as the campaign committee’s treasurer at the time.
Pedroza’s airport votes
On 9 June 2020, Pedroza moved to defer changes to Napa Jet Center’s lease and license until the county had received and accepted proposals. Ryan Gregory seconded the motion, which failed 2–3. After the bids came in, Pedroza joined the unanimous 20 October vote approving amendments that freed space for redevelopment. The minutes of the final lease vote on 6 December 2022 list him as absent.
The 313-point proposal went without a lease
Napa County’s 2019 competition was for a second fixed-base operator, a company that provides services such as fueling and hangar space. The incumbent was to keep the east site. The county sought a competitor for the west site and received three bids in July 2020.
| Bidder | Points / 400 | Result |
|---|---|---|
| J3 Jet | 313 | No lease awarded |
| Napa Valley AVAtion | 296 | Withdrew in April 2021 |
| Ocean Aviation | 197 | No lease awarded |
The totals put J3 Jet 17 points ahead of AVAtion, but the scoring sheets alone do not explain the county’s negotiating choice. The grand jury reported that officials considered the bidder it called Respondent Two willing to meet the requirements but lacking the operating record and assets needed to succeed. Its account also described interviewees’ concerns about political advocacy for Respondent One. The county’s selection memorandum and financial-capacity assessment are therefore central to explaining how the ranking translated into negotiations.
County staff said they negotiated with two respondents. The grand jury reported that the county chose the west-site proposal from the bidder it anonymized as Respondent One. Napa Valley AVAtion’s bid matches the report’s description. It proposed a $14.25 million west-site plan and a $30 million plan covering both sites. AVAtion withdrew in April 2021, citing the economics of a two-operator airport and the proposed lease terms, then backed the incumbent’s single-operator plan. The grand jury could not establish why AVAtion backed the incumbent after withdrawing.
The county negotiated both final leases directly
The county says it decided on 23 June 2021 to make no award under the competition. Atlantic Aviation acquired the Lynx network that November, taking over Napa’s incumbent operation. On 6 December 2022, supervisors approved 30-year leases with Atlantic and Skyservice. Each committed at least $13.6 million in capital improvements. The $1 sale to Atlantic covered the existing fuel tanks and distribution equipment. County staff cited the equipment’s short remaining useful life and the cost of vacating the site.
The grand jury found credible allegations of leaks
In findings 14–16, the civil grand jury judged credible multiple firsthand accounts of misuse or overuse of closed Board sessions and leaks of confidential information by non-county staff to unauthorized recipients, including airport operators negotiating with the county. It concluded that leaks, excessive secrecy and divisions among county leaders undercut the competition and staff, complicated negotiations and prolonged the process.
The county disputed those findings, saying supporting evidence had not been provided. On leaks, it nevertheless acknowledged sufficient anecdotal evidence to justify concern about the appearance of impropriety and promised confidentiality training. These findings do not identify Murray or Pedroza as a source or recipient of leaked information.
The state email and the county’s audit
The grand jury reported that a state business-development office favored Respondent One and asserted that two supervisors and the county executive backed it as the sole operator. County staff disputed that account. The county’s November 2026 release notice for request 26-1550 identifies an email file titled “RE GO-Biz Introduction Napa County Airport.” Whether it contains the message described by the grand jury, and whom it names, remains unverified.
The Board declined the grand jury’s recommendation to review the selection process and present its findings publicly. Auditor-Controller Tracy Schulze agreed to a narrower review of compliance with county purchasing policy. The county lists the review as completed on 27 June 2023 and reported to the grand jury on 12 July. The register contains the dates. The findings of the review are absent from that entry.
The earlier Murray and Pedroza records
The seven earlier reports document Murray’s campaign-treasurer service; a $13,639.67 advertising package reported by two committees; a $2,500 Pearls Farm Labor refund; a $4,900 company contribution 80 days after a 2021 rate vote; his assessment-appeals-board appointments; and the FPPC’s $200 penalty for delayed income disclosures. They also distinguish the city franchise company, Napa Recycling and Waste Services LLC, from the county Zone One contractor, Napa County Recycling and Waste Services LLC, and document Murray’s CFO role at both. The linked reports retain the underlying filings and source widgets.
Murray and Pedroza — the seven earlier reports (7)
- reported date
- 2022-06-30
- reporting as
- nonmonetary contributions through an intermediary
- recipient committee
- 1374964
- intermediary committee
- 1449337
- url
- https://miscsubjects.com/library/media/0c62ed81-053b-4f5b-93f2-bf0c2e4df5c2
- locator
- Page 4
- contract
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.json
- fact ids
- fact:murray:2022-ad-package, fact:murray:local-people-410
- url
- https://miscsubjects.com/library/media/0805a98a-9e33-4995-b64a-db62781d2e9b
- locator
- Page 9
- contract
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.json
- fact ids
- fact:murray:cfo-and-2019-rate-vote, fact:murray:2021-rate-vote-and-contribution
- contract
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.json
- fact ids
- fact:murray:pearls-refund, fact:murray:2022-ad-package
- plain text
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.txt?view=facts
- contract
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.json
- fact ids
- fact:murray:treasurer-1374964
- plain text
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.txt?view=facts
- contract
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.json
- fact ids
- fact:murray:assessment-appeals-board-tenure
- plain text
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.txt?view=facts
- contract
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.json
- fact ids
- fact:murray:fppc-14-1317
- plain text
- https://miscsubjects.com/graph/pedroza.txt?view=facts
Decisions still to be established
The Chamber’s board minutes or endorsement authorization would establish who approved Stanley’s letter and whether Murray participated. Correspondence or an agreement between AVAtion and Napa Recycling would establish how the proposed vendor relationship arose. The county’s selection memorandum and advocacy correspondence would establish the reasons for proceeding with AVAtion and the participation of individual officials.
The proposal’s July 2020 date precedes the March 2021 formation of Napa Valley AVATION, LLC recorded in the research workbook. The proposal identifies Scott L. Powell and the Superior Aviation operation. The applicant’s original legal capacity and any subsequent assignment to the LLC require the original signature and assignment records. The later formation date alone leaves that sequence unresolved.
The GO-Biz message and the completed procurement review could establish what officials were told and whether the selection followed county policy. Their substantive contents remain the material gaps in the airport record.
References (16)
- Napa Valley AVAtion proposal and Chamber endorsement — Napa County Public Works, Jul 17, 2020
- Napa Chamber names Michael Murray its 2020 board chair — Napa Chamber of Commerce, Jan 1, 2020
- Friends of Alfredo Pedroza for Supervisor — Form 410 history — California Secretary of State, Political Reform Division, Jul 25, 2023
- Board vote on the Zone One waste rate increase — Napa County Board of Supervisors, Sep 24, 2019
- Pedroza’s motion to defer action on the incumbent’s agreements — Napa County Board of Supervisors, Jun 9, 2020
- Board approval of the Napa Jet Center lease and license amendments — Napa County Board of Supervisors, Oct 20, 2020
- Airport bid evaluation sheets — Napa County Public Works, Jan 1, 2020
- Under the Radar — The saga to bring Napa’s airport into the 21st century — Napa County Civil Grand Jury, Jun 21, 2022
- County records request 26-1550 — Napa County Public Records, Nov 16, 2026
- Atlantic reports its purchase of the Lynx network — Napa County Airport Advisory Commission, Dec 6, 2021
- Atlantic and Skyservice lease terms — Napa County Public Works, Dec 6, 2022
- Board approves both airport leases — Napa County Board of Supervisors, Dec 6, 2022
- County and Auditor-Controller responses to the grand jury — Napa County, Jan 1, 2022
- Airport procurement review recorded as completed — Napa County Auditor-Controller, Jul 18, 2023
- Ownership Web — airport records and original document locators — Research workbook
- The proposal names Napa Recycling in two operating plans — Napa County Public Works, Jul 17, 2020