Everything tagged adjudication

33 published articles · newest first · server-rendered

Also filed under: governance 16 · use-case 10 · evidence 7 · ruleset 6 · decision-constitution 5 · eu-ai-act 4 · evaluation 4 · calibration 3 · provenance 3 · records-absent 3 · self-authored 3 · abstention 2 · assurance 2 · canonical 2

1. Four AI models judged one EU AI Act disclosure — sealed record-bound APPROVE, with the discarded finding printed
2. Three measurements from one 70-finding suite: vendor diversity beats panel size, the second channel is the cheapest, and the published error floor was three times too good
3. The five-model panel never returned a denial, and the cause was three seats returning nothing at all
4. A model cited clauses 7, 8 and 12 of a three-clause rule set and passed the consistency check
5. A pulmonary nodule was reported on a chest scan; no follow-up was completed
6. Clinical endpoint committees preserve the verdict but discard the reasoning that produced it
7. How an independent authorization gate can stop an AI agent before its action executes
8. A DSA takedown notice should preserve the policy clauses, evidence, and rejected alternative
9. Auditors are being asked to sign off on AI systems with no evidence to stand on. This is the missing piece
10. How an AI evidence record keeps a hiring-bias audit current between annual reviews
11. Thirty cases with known answers run through the live decision gate: seat accuracy, wrongful authorisations, and deferral cost
12. Making 'cannot conclude' a recorded, comparable outcome instead of a non-answer
13. EU AI Act Article 12 logging and Article 14 oversight have no technical method to check against — this is a candidate
14. Nobody can insure an AI's mistakes without knowing how often it is wrong. This table is that number
15. The Fed requires independent validation of models. For large language models no instrument existed — here is one
16. Two models reached the same verdict citing different clauses; the gate now compares the reasoning, not the answer
17. How three system prompts changed the audit record produced from the same AI decision
18. The rule set, the model's clause-by-clause reasoning, and the action it authorised, stored as one replayable record
19. An insurer denied a lumbar MRI after two weeks of therapy; the policy required six
20. A real outage did not earn a service credit because the customer missed the contract’s claim deadline
21. A 235,000-share purchase stayed under the board’s ceiling but triggered a notice the record cannot prove
    A synthetic board resolution treated as the rule set — provenance counterparty-authored — with a hashed trade blotter. Cumulative acquisitions of 235,000 shares sit inside the 250,000 ceiling and past
22. Were the risk controls on before the algorithm started trading — and can anyone prove it?
    17 CFR 240.15c3-5(c)(1)(i) quoted verbatim, a synthetic order-flow record hashed before deliberation, four channels split between DENY and CANNOT_CONCLUDE on whether a disabled price collar settles th
23. Four models were given EU AI Act Article 12 verbatim and all four refused to answer — correctly
    Articles 12 and 14 of the AI Act supplied verbatim and hashed before the run, under a rule set reused at its existing hash. Every conforming channel returned CANNOT_CONCLUDE because applicability turn
24. An assembly that refuses to emit when its members disagree, and the error bound it still lacks
    The unit is not a model's answer but an assembly: rules pinned at a hash, artifact hashed first, N blinded adjudicators citing their clauses, a derivation-level divergence check, and a deterministic g
25. Rule set: does this position exceed what the board authorised?
    Do the supplied records establish that an executive action exceeded a limit, condition, or authority granted by the supplied governing resolution, such that a notification obligation in that resolutio
26. Rule set: were the required pre-trade risk controls in place before the order flow?
    Do the supplied records establish that the financial risk management controls and supervisory procedures required before order entry were in place and operative at the time the order flow was sent?
27. The measured error rate of this adjudication panel, per model and per rule set, including where it is unflattering
    Known-answer probes through the identical adjudication path: four rates per model, the agreement statistics with the right estimators, and the prevalence paradox named in this system's own numbers.
28. Is this answer right, what was the model given, and what did it never receive
    One attested finding, end to end: a hashed synthetic radiograph, a hashed medication record, a pinned rule set, the full system prompt, four adjudication seats with their receipts including two provid
29. Five models, one pinned rule set, and one question under EU AI Act Article 50 — the full receipted decision
    A worked adjudication on Article 50(2) of the EU AI Act: five blinded adjudicators under a hash-pinned rule set with declared statutory provenance, an artifact hashed before the panel ran, a published
30. Rule set: is this the same individual?
    Does the supplied evidence establish that the individual in the query image is the same individual as in the reference? Rules pinned at SHA-256 e3f91b3b3733ca97, declared provenance: self-authored.
31. Rule set: was this specific record in that dataset?
    Does the supplied evidence establish that the specific record was present in the named dataset? Rules pinned at SHA-256 427e366b460fa213, declared provenance: self-authored.
32. Rule set: does an AI Act obligation apply to this system?
    Under the cited provision of Regulation (EU) 2024/1689 (the AI Act), does the stated obligation apply to the described system as characterised? Rules pinned at SHA-256 0dd9afef93503a92, declared prove
33. Rule set: does the cited source support the claim?
    Does the cited source support the claim as stated? Rules pinned at SHA-256 f26b7f104a5887dd, declared provenance: self-authored.

Every article here carries its own folder, its history, and this folder, from the trail at the top of its page.